Get our issue, highlights, free stuff and more.  

St. Matthew’s Tavern offers bar and church in one

December 3, 2013


1300 N. Mills Ave. has been home to the oddest collection of bars. Once it was known as Paradise, a neighborhood gay bar owned by the same people who own Ivanhoe Village gay bar the Savoy. Paradise had super-cheap drinks and free hot dogs on the patio on Sundays. Then Paradise closed, and it became Orlando Nights, which we never could get a good feel for. It wasn’t a gay bar, but it also wasn’t much of anything else – it hosted music, had drink specials and tried to appeal to everyone. But there was never any “there” there.

Now, according to info published in the Bungalower, it’s a bar where you can also go to church. St. Matthew’s Tavern, as it’s now being called, was open for church services on Sunday, hosted by the St. Dorothy’s Catholic Community, an group that celebrates “love without judgment flowing from Catholic Apostolic tradition.” Unlike traditional Catholic church communities (which would probably not approve of the church-bar concept), St. Dorothy’s welcomes members who are divorced, gay or “recovering” Catholic. Not affiliated with the Roman Catholic Diocese, just FYI.

According to St. Dorothy’s website, St. Matthew’s Tavern will be the church’s temporary home while it waits until it can move back to its permanent home at the corner of New York and Lyman avenues in Winter Park. So for now, St. Dorothy’s will hold services at St. Matthew’s Tavern every Sunday at 11 a.m. They’ll even hold a Midnight Mass there on Christmas Eve.

This is going to bring a whole new dimension to the pub crawl experience in Mills50.

(H/T: Bungalower)

Tags: , ,

  • Michael Davis

    I shall avoid making any connections between altar boys, priests, and “crawling.”

  • juggernaut866

    What about straight people? Are we welcomed?

  • Elaine

    Yes! Our motto is: “All Are Welcome.” We have both straight and gay members. One of the straight members stated that she hoped having Mass at St. Matthew’s would bring both communities closer together. Amen! Come. Experience St. Dorothy’s for yourself. Bring a friend

  • Gregory

    I plan to come this Sunday. It will be my first attendance at a Catholic service, but this makes me want to attend for some reason. I don’t want to resist the calling :)

  • James F Profirio-Bond

    You are always welcome any Sunday at 11:00am. We will also be having Midnight Mass on Christmas Eve